How to Figure Out Why Your Car Won’t Start

Nothing is more frustrating than jumping into your car, turning the key (or pressing the button), and… nothing happens. Your car won’t start. Whether you’re rushing to work, heading out for errands, or picking up the kids, a car refusing to start is a situation no one wants to deal with. 

There are plenty of potential culprits, from something as simple as an empty fuel tank to more complex issues like a faulty starter motor. Understanding why your car won’t start and knowing the proper troubleshooting steps can save you time, money, and stress. 

This guide breaks down the common reasons for car starting problems, how to diagnose them, and practical advice on what to do next. 

Call 317-571-0800 if Your German Car Won't Start in Indianapolis Indiana
Call 317-571-0800 if Your German Car Won’t Start in Indianapolis Indiana

Typical Car Starting Problems

Battery Issues 

The battery is the heart of your car’s electrical system. When there’s a problem, your car won’t start—but diagnosing the issue is simpler than you think.

Dead or Weak Battery 

A dead or weak battery is one of the most common reasons why your car refuses to start. 

How to Check 

  • Turn the key to the “ON” position and check the dashboard lights. If the lights are dim or don’t turn on, it’s likely your battery. 
  • Use a multimeter to measure the voltage. A reading below 12.4 volts means the battery is weak. 

How to Fix It 

  • Jump-start the car: 
  1. Connect the positive (+) terminal of the dead battery to the positive terminal of a working battery. 
  2. Attach the negative (-) terminal of the working battery to an unpainted metal surface on the car with the dead battery (not directly to the battery). 
  3. Start the working car and wait a few minutes, then try starting your car. 
  4. Have the battery tested at Autohaus Dierolf to determine if it needs replacement.

Corroded Battery Terminals 

Even if the battery isn’t dead, corroded connections can block electrical flow. 

How to Spot It 

  • Look for white or bluish-green buildup around the battery terminals. 

How to Fix 

  • Disconnect the cables (start with the negative). Use a battery terminal cleaner or baking soda mixed with water to remove the corrosion.
  • Reconnect the cables securely. 

Starter Problems 

If your battery checks out but your car still won’t start, the culprit may be the starter motor. 

Faulty Starter Motor 

The starter motor is responsible for cranking your engine to get it running. 

Signs of a Starter Problem 

  • A clicking noise when you turn the key.
  • Dashboard lights dim significantly when you try to start the car. 
  • A burning smell or smoke (rare but critical). 

Quick Fix

  • Try gently tapping the starter with a wrench while someone else attempts to start the car. This can temporarily “unstick” the solenoid. 

If these steps fail, the starter motor likely needs professional repair or replacement. 

Schedule Automotive Diagnostic Testing Today

Fuel System Issues 

Even the most powerful engine won’t run without fuel. Problems in your car’s fuel system can lead to frustrating starting issues, but most of them are easy to diagnose and fix.

Empty Fuel Tank 

It may sound obvious, but overlooking this simple issue is common. Sometimes, drivers misjudge how much fuel they have left or forget to refuel.    

What to Do 

  • Check your fuel gauge. If it’s low or empty, add fuel and try starting again. 
  • If needed, add fuel and try starting the car again. If the car still doesn’t start, there could be another issue at play, such as a problem with the fuel pump or fuel line. 

Clogged Fuel Filter 

The fuel filter plays a crucial role in keeping debris and impurities from entering the engine. Over time, it can become clogged, restricting or completely blocking the flow of fuel. This can lead to serious performance issues or prevent the car from starting altogether. 

Signs 

  • The car starts but stalls quickly.
  • Poor engine performance when running. 

Solution 

  • Replacing a fuel filter is routine maintenance.
  • Check your service schedule to avoid this problem in the future. 

Malfunctioning Fuel Pump 

The fuel pump transfers fuel to the engine. If it fails, your car won’t start. 

How to Check and Fix

  • Turn the key to the “ON” position and listen for a whirring sound near the fuel tank. If you don’t hear it, the pump may be faulty. 
  • A qualified mechanic can run a fuel pressure test to confirm the issue. 

Ignition System Faults 

The ignition system is vital for creating the spark needed to ignite the engine’s air-fuel mixture. 

Bad Spark Plugs 

Worn or fouled spark plugs are a frequent culprit in cars that won’t start. 

What to Do

  • Remove the spark plugs and inspect them for damage or deposits. 
  • Replace worn or damaged spark plugs with new ones. 

Faulty Ignition Coils 

Ignition coils generate the high voltage needed for the spark plugs to work.  If you suspect ignition coil trouble, have them tested at Autohaus Dierolf for accuracy. 

Symptoms 

  • Engine misfires 
  • Reduced fuel efficiency 

Other Potential Issues 

While battery, starter, fuel, and ignition problems cover most cases, here are additional possibilities for those experiencing persistent trouble:

Faulty Car Computer (ECU) 

Modern vehicles, especially complex ones like BMW, Volkswagen, Mercedes-Benz, and Porsche, rely heavily on an Engine Control Unit (ECU). If the ECU malfunctions, it can confuse the starting system. 

Solution

  • Visit Autohaus Dierolf for a car diagnostic service to pinpoint the issue. 

Anti-Theft System Issues 

Many German cars have advanced anti-theft systems. If activated unintentionally, they may prevent the car from starting. 

What to Do 

  • Look for the anti-theft symbol on your dashboard. If it’s flashing, your system may need to be reset according to your car’s manual. 

Avoid These Common Mistakes When Troubleshooting 

  • Overlooking obvious issues like an empty fuel tank. 
  • Incorrect jump-starting that damages your car’s electrical system. 
  • Neglecting corroded battery terminals, which is often a quick fix. 
  • Ignoring warning signs, like clicking or whirring sounds. 
  • Assuming it’s always the battery without testing it first. 
  • Replacing parts unnecessarily without verifying the root cause. 
  • Postponing professional diagnostics, which can save you from more expensive repairs later. 

Take Action to Get Back on the Road 

Car starting problems are stressful, but knowing the common causes makes troubleshooting manageable. Whether it’s a weak battery, a failing starter motor, or a clogged fuel filter, addressing these issues early can prevent bigger headaches down the road. 

If your car won’t start and you’re unsure why, schedule a diagnostic service at Autohaus Dierolf today. Our expert mechanics in Indianapolis specialize in German cars like BMW, Volkswagen, and Audi, and will get you back on the road quickly and safely. 

Book Your Appointment Now

Related Post: Engine Stalling and Misfires: Causes, Solutions, and Prevention